Writing it made me really angry.
So angry that I felt it necessary to sit on it, and reflect on why I hate The Wombats so much.
Through reflection, I’ve realised that I don’t hate The Wombats, and their status as All Points East 2020 headliners is not a good reason to tell people to rip up their festival tickets (if yours is digital you can still smash up your phone – go on, I dare you).
Anyway, while you should still definitely NOT go to All Points East 2020, I’ll get to that in a bit.
Deconstructing why I hate The Wombats so much made me realise that actually, hating a band intensely is a real symptom of fanboyism / fangirlism / fanthemism. Because it’s the mirror-image of dogmatically repeating what you think is cool, and holding opinions that make no sense (the definition of fanboyism). Which makes sense, because that’s what music encourages you to do, by embedding lyrics and tunes in your head, over and over again.
But I don’t think dogmatism’s cool, so I decided to change my mind about The Wombats.
Here’s how I did it.
Why I Thought I Hated The Wombats
I started by rekindling my intense hatred for The Wombats.
This was achieved by spending most of last week listening to their first album, A Guide To Love, Loss and Desperation. Wanky title, isn’t it?
Listening to it again helped me distil this hatred into four key points, which I wrote down and then felt pretty stupid about.
Here are the reasons.
They’re stupid, aren’t they?
1. The Wombats’ Lyrics Really Make Me Cringe
I don’t know why, but the lyrics in Wombats’ songs always make me cringe.
Take the singles from their debut album:
Kill The Director
Kill The Director involves the frontman finding himself in a situation that plays out as if it’s a romantic comedy or Eastenders episode, and references how ‘carrots help you see much better in the dark’.
Moving To New York
Moving To New York is about how Matthew Murphy is going to move to New York because he’s got insomnia.
My gripe with this song is that he sings it as if he hasn’t considered that the cost of Manhattan apartment (because he’d totally live in Manhattan) would make his insomnia worse.
It’s also like it was written in reaction to an episode in which Matthew Murphy’s parents forced him to revise for his General Studies AS-Level, and his very mature reaction was to run around the kitchen table, waving his hands in the air, saying that he was going to slit his wrists because General Studies is definitely way too hard.
Let’s Dance To Joy Division
Let’s Dance To Joy Division is apparently about how the singer was in a pub in Liverpool and everyone was dancing to Joy Division (it’s alluded that the song was Love Will Tear Us Apart Again, and I think fair to assume, because that’s probably the only Joy Division song that people who listen to The Wombats know).
The chorus hinges on how ironic dancing to Joy Division is, because I dunno, Joy Division songs are about being sad, and people never dance to sad songs when they’re happy. Yeah, that’s totally a reason people don’t dance to songs isn’t it?
So yeah, I don’t think there’s anything ironic about dancing to Joy Division, and in context it comes off as a song dedicated to what I assume is Matthew Murphy’s snarky, yet poorly justified, superiority complex.
As you can see, most of my hatred here is based on a completely imagined version of Matthew Murphy. It’s like he must have stolen my girlfriend back in 2006 (ha! I didn’t have a girlfriend).
And when I think about this, it’s totally unfair. Because he’s probably quite nice, and definitely writes better lyrics than I do.
2. My Sixth Form Tutor Said They Were Shit
My sixth form tutor, Mrs Blay, used to let us pick music to play during morning registration.
One morning, a girl I didn’t like kept requesting on The Wombats. Mrs Blay proceeded to say they were shit.
I didn’t like that girl. I really hated that girl. So by association, I started hating The Wombats.
3. They Remind Me Of Mid-2000s ‘Indie’ TopShop Girls Who Wouldn’t Go Out With Me
I remember The Wombats as a band liked by teenage girls who’s rock / indie credentials were store bought from TopShop in the early 2000s.
Remember that uniform of stupid hats, plaid shirts, skinny jeans, oversized sunglasses and unwavering sense of superiority (over the other girls, who just didn’t understand real music)?
I don’t know why, but this really annoyed me.
Perhaps it’s because at the time, the coolest attributes I had were owning a copy of the Pixies’ fourth LP, not understanding Daydream Nation and a pretentious aversion to Best Ofs. It was also that none of the girls appreciated just how cool all of those attributes were.
4. The Wombats Are Really Inoffensive
Listen to their songs.
They’re not hurting anyone are they?
I don’t know why, but I’ve always felt like music should like say something in a pseudo-it’s-not-saying-anything-but-it-makes-you-feel-better-about-listening-to-it sort of way.
Why? I don’t know. It’s just a stupid pretension.
Why The Wombats Are Not A Good Reason To Avoid All Points East 2020
Having written down the reasons I hated The Wombats, I realised that they’re all really, really stupid and I should stop hating The Wombats immediately.
I mean, the more I think about it, the more I’m sure that The Wombats are probably alright.
It’s also impressive that they’ve managed to make a lot of money as a reasonably cookie cutter indie band, and are now headlining a reasonably big UK (day) festival almost fifteen years after they were relevant.
Finally, they’re getting a bunch of idiots to pay for their retirement, which I think we can all totally applaud.
Why You Still Shouldn’t Go To All Points East 2020
But although I’ve stopped hating The Wombats, I still don’t think you should go to All Points East 2020 and here’s why.
1. It’s Has-Been Central
With the exception of Tame Impala, all six days are a complete nostalgia trip.
Correct me if I’m wrong, but I’m pretty sure it wasn’t in the last decade?
So you already know that everyone there’s going to be reminiscing about how the last time they listened to [insert band] they could still see their penis / vagina over their now enormous beer gut.
Is that how you want to spend two weekends?
Hanging out with those types?
2. The Free-Entry Activities Sound Shit
That’s a quote from the video explaining All Points East’s new, free programme of mid-week activities. It’s like it justifies how the festival is now commandeering a large portion of Victoria Park for another weekend.
While I guess it’s great that they’re pretending to do something for the local community this year, it doesn’t sound like much.
Wait, let me rephrase that. It sounds like a completely hollow cop out.
I mean, how does food, film and a circus sound any better than sitting around in the sun with your friends, watching half naked people (cinema), drinking bottled beer (food), while Australians throw rugby balls in your direction (circus)?
It doesn’t sound any different at all. If anything, my version includes more nudity.
Also, they say this portion is free, but I’m sure the food isn’t going to be.
So it’s probably just another justification for them to charge vendors more for the privilege of selling overpriced food.
3. It’s STILL Commercialisation To The MAX
American Express and Firestone are still sponsoring the event.
Which means that there’ll be a special wristband area for twats who have American Express cards, or eat tires.
While I guess it’s a positive that such dickheads will be segregated from the wider crowd, the concept is still dreadful, and if you go to All Points East 2020, you’re endorsing it.
4. It Means You Don’t Read My Blog Enough
My review clearly explains why it was so bad last year.
While I’m not clairvoyant, given there are three more days of it this year, I can and will definitively predict that it’s going to be worse this year (or was there a whole two weeks last year? I really don’t remember)
Given the evidence, why would you go?
Why I’ll Probably Go To All Points East 2020 Anyway
So, now you know why it’s not The Wombats’ fault that All Points East 2020 is going to suck. It was going to anyway!
Also, you now know why you should revise your opinion of The Wombats too.
Despite all of these brilliant reasons not to go to the day festival, both you and I are probably still going to.
Because honestly, what else are we going to do? Balloons?